Debunking Political Myths

Republicans On Civil Rights, and was Martin Luther King a Republican?

Posted on December 24, 2013 | in Stories | by

mlk-republicanThis image is a mixture of fact and fiction. Lets break it down by claim.

First is the pictures of “Republicans”

From left to right, of Abraham Lincoln, Frederick Douglass, and Martin Luther King, Jr. Abraham Lincoln [true] is known for being the first Republican President [1]. Frederick Douglass was definitely a republican  [true]  also, he made statements such as:

“I am a Republican, a black, dyed in the wool Republican, and I never intend to belong to any other party than the party of freedom and progress.”

He also made some fairly anti-Lincoln statements such as  calling Lincoln “the white man’s president” and cited his tardiness in joining the cause of emancipation. He noted that Lincoln initially opposed the expansion of slavery but did not support its elimination. He also said in a speech “Though Mr. Lincoln shared the prejudices of his white fellow-countrymen against the Negro, it is hardly necessary to say that in his heart of hearts he loathed and hated slavery….” [2]

Next is… Martin Luther King Jr.

[false] He was definitely not a Republican, and I’m  not sure if he was put here in an attempt to make people believe something not true, or if it was an accident. King and his wife were pretty quiet about their political affiliations for the most part but here are some known facts about his party choices:

In a 1958 Interview King said: “I don’t think the Republican party is a party full of the almighty God nor is the Democratic party. They both have weaknesses … And I’m not inextricably bound to either party.” [3]
Martin Luther King III said in an AP Report that “It is disingenuous to imply that my father was a Republican” [4]
The King Center of Atlanta founded by MLK’s wife says he wasn’t a republican [5]
The King Center also said King didn’t officially endorse any party [5]
Kings niece Alveda King said he was, then said: “I regret having said to a group of peers that my Uncle M. L. (Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.) was a Republican. I said that without having all the facts.” [6][7]
King had said himself in his autobiography: I always voted the Democratic ticket. [8]

Kings  wife said they didn’t identify with either party

there is no evidence that he registered republican
Throughout the Civil Rights movement he worked with the northern Democratic Party

Next on the list is “Republicans abolished Slavery”

[true] This is mostly true, as the Republicans in the House and Senate had majorities and had most of the passing votes. The senate vote was 38 to 6, with 34 Republican votes, 3 Democrat votes, and 1 Unconditional Unionist vote [votes]

The house vote was 119-56, with 84 Republicans voting for, 14 Democrats for, and 49 Democrats voting against with another 8 not voting. [vote] Clearly very few Democrats supported it, but a few still did.

Next is “Republicans Gave Blacks the Vote”

[false] The The Voting Rights Act of 1965 was jointly sponsored by a Democrat and Republican (Senate Majority Leader Mike Mansfield (D-MT) and Senate Minority Leader Everett Dirksen (R-IL))  at a time when Democrats had a filibuster proof Senate. Initially, Dirksen did not intend to support voting rights legislation, but President Johnson enlisted Dirksen to help gain Republican support. The finals votes where definitely a Democrat effort with some Republican help.

The Final senate vote was 77-19 with 47 Democrats and 30 Republicans voting for, and 16 Democrats against and 2 Republicans voting against. [vote]

The Final House vote was 333-85 with 221 Democrats voting for it, and 111 Republicans voting for it, and 62 Democrats voting against and 23 Republicans voting against. [vote]

The Republicans Passed the Civil Rights act

[false] The Civil Rights Act of 1964 was President Kennedy’s idea and the Senate had a Democratic Majority.  Senate Minority Leader Everett Dirksen  (R-IL) and Senate Majority Leader Mike Mansfield (D-MT) both voiced support for the president’s bill and was initially introduced in the House as H.R. 7152 by Emanuel Celler (D–NY) . While it would not have likely passed without some Republican support, it was written by Democrats, introduced by Democrats, and passed in Democrat Majority house and senate with a majority of Democrat votes, and signed by a Democrat President.

The Final Senate vote was 73-27 with 46 Democrats, 27 Republicans voting for, and 20 Democrats, 7 Republicans voting against. [vote]

The Final House vote was 290-130 with 152 Democrats, 138 Republicans voting for, and 96 Democrats, 34 Republicans voting against. [vote]

First Black Republican Senator

[true] Though the date is off by one year, Hiram Rhodes Revels took office in 1870, as the First Black Republican Senator.

First Black Democrat Senator

[true] Carol Moseley Braun was the first black Democrat voted into senate, in 1999.

50% of Black Senators have been Republican

[close] There have been 9 Black Senators in office, 4 Republicans, and 5 Democrats 44% Republican, and 55% Democrat. All 5 Democrats have been elected since 1999, but only one Republican in the same time, with the other 3 being in the 1800’s, and 1960’s.

The First 22 Black Representatives

[close]  The first 21 black Representatives were Republicans, #22 was Democrat Arthur Wergs Mitchell. This is still mostly true though, however the next 42 in a row and 105 out of 127 total (83%) have been Democrats.

bibliography

[1] The Presidents of the United States of America,” by Frank Freidel  and Hugh Sidey. ( 2006 )
[2] David W. Blight, Frederick Douglass’ Civil War: Keeping Faith in Jubilee (1989)
[3] The Martin Luther King, Jr. Papers Project
[4] Associated Press, July 4, 2008
[5]  The National Journal July 12, 2008
[6]  Alveda King’s Blog
[7] Twitter / Alveda King
[
8] The Papers of Martin Luther King, Jr, page 384




Whether their slogan is “compassionate conservatism” or “hawkish liberalism,” political parties have always sought to expand their electoral coalitions by making minor adjustments to their public image. How do voters respond to these, often short-term, campaign appeals? Race, Republicans, and the Return of the Party of Lincoln is Tasha Philpot’s insightful study of how parties use racial images to shape and reshape the way citizens perceive them.

 

“Philpot has produced a timely, provocative, and nuanced analysis of political party image change, using the Republican Party’s attempts to recast itself as a party sensitive to issues of race with its 2000, and later 2004, national conventions as case examples. Using a mixture of experiments, focus groups, national surveys, and analyses of major national and black newspaper articles, Philpot finds that if race-related issues are important to individuals, such as blacks, the ability of the party to change its image without changing its political positions is far more difficult than it is among individuals who do not consider race-related issues important, e.g., whites. This book makes a major contribution

to our understanding of party image in general, and political parties’ use of race in particular. Bravo!”

—Paula D. McClain, Duke University

 

“This book does an excellent job of illuminating the linkages between racial images and partisan support. By highlighting Republican efforts to ‘play against type’ Philpot emphasizes the limits of successfully altering partisan images. That she accomplishes this in the controversial, yet salient, domain of race is no small feat. In short, by focusing on a topical issue, and by adopting a novel theoretical approach, Philpot is poised to make a significant contribution to the literatures on race and party images.”

—Vincent Hutchings, University of Michigan

 

Tasha S. Philpot is Assistant Professor of Government and African and African American Studies at the University of Texas at Austin.

List Price: $26.95 USD
New From: $20.21 USD In Stock
Used from: $20.18 USD In Stock

One Response to “Republicans On Civil Rights, and was Martin Luther King a Republican?”

  1. Ditolus says:

    u do realize that back in the days of slavery that you u are referring to, republicans were the liberals and the democrats were the conservatives. u might want to read up on your history. the names are just semantics. the 2 parties have evolved since then of course, but liberalism and conservatism havent

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Sponsors

Findings:

FALSE = Claim is Untrue
TRUE = Claim is True
MIXED = Answer has varying answers
UNKNOWN = No data/answer found or available

These are used for Numerical claims:
FALSE+ = Untrue because figure is higher than claim
FALSE- = Untrue because figure is lower than claim
TRUE+ = True because figure is higher than claim
TRUE- = True because figure is lower than claim
Email
Print